Pokémon Art Academy Community
Hanabusa25thAlice2
03/19/2016 4:36 PM ·Spoilers
Share this Post
Comment
This post has no comments.
-
03/19/2016 5:36 PM ·Spoilers
Pretty good! I'm digging how you're aiming for that semi-realism but still keeping your style. I think the lips/mouth is positioned a little off. It's facing a bit too forward and nudged too far to the right.
Yeahs2 -
-
03/19/2016 6:09 PM ·Spoilers
For criticism, there isn't too much to say- your shading is fantastic! The only major problem I see is the eyes. There a little big proportion-wise. Other than that it looks great!
Yeahs1Played -
03/19/2016 6:16 PM ·Spoilers
Aww yeah supernatural ^o^ I gotta get back to that show.. I'm still on season 7. I gotta say the show gets real silly in the later seasons As for the drawing, I suggest blending out the contours on the right side of the face And maybe adding some more backlighting to the hair and jacket Its lookin super good though •0•)b Dean is my favourite too
Yeahs3Played -
03/19/2016 6:18 PM ·Spoilers
Finer lines if possible with slightly more definition. That way things don't blend into the background. Hmmm... Other than that I believe the other comments have it covered. Still a great art piece doh!
Yeahs2 -
03/19/2016 8:44 PM ·Spoilers
As my art teacher says "needs more contrast, could use more development in certain areas, Angel stop poking people with the paintbrush"... wise words. o-o
Yeahs2Played -
03/19/2016 9:38 PM ·Spoilers
Im on season two. Much catch up. Yeah, proportions are definitely my big thing to work on, though with a lot of the lighting, especially on the jacket, the way it comes out on miiverse, it darkens up a lot so ill have to lighten it. Thank you guys for your opinions and ideas OuO
Yeahs1Played -
03/19/2016 9:39 PM ·Spoilers
If I were to offer a negative criticism, would I be trolled, blocked and maybe reported? I mean, you're asking for criticisms, but what if I DID offer a negative criticism? Arguing hypotheticals here.
This comment contains spoilers.
Yeahs0 -
03/19/2016 9:45 PM ·Spoilers
Ooos, wrote the response on the wrong account. My response is just two upXD @uncle V It does say constructive criticism, to help me improve in this particular style of portrait. If you want to be rude just for the sake of it, I will do whatever actions are necessary.
Yeahs2Played -
03/20/2016 10:50 AM ·Spoilers
See? I haven't even said a thing about the drawing and I'm faced with a "tread lightly, sensitive audience." message. I simply asked what would happen in the hypothetical event that I come and say something bad about this drawing, and you lay out that message about how you'll "do whatever it takes." You don't even know what I think about it.
This comment contains spoilers.
Yeahs0 -
03/20/2016 11:27 AM ·Spoilers
That's because you haven't actually SAID anything that pertains to the art piece, you've just stated that you might say something bad about it....
Yeahs1Played -
03/20/2016 11:46 AM ·Spoilers
You can't assume that my theoretical negative comment is going to be rude, but I have to ask if it'll get me in trouble. (I blame no one.) I'm not scared to speak my mind, I just need to know if I'll still be able to afterward.
Yeahs0 -
03/20/2016 11:52 AM ·Spoilers
@imagizine Thank you for understanding. @uncle v You don't understand what constructive critism is, do you? And if you have to ask permission to put a negative comment, then of course people will assume its rude. And if you think you have to tread lightly or whatever, I dont really care. Say what u want or not, but dont beat around the bush and not say it at all but allude to it.
This comment contains spoilers.
Yeahs1Played -
03/20/2016 12:00 PM ·Spoilers
Actually I'd like a definition of that word when I'm done. I need to explain it to other people too. Anyway, this is some of the best semi-realistic stuff I've seen in a long time. But I think he (and this is the part I was flaking over.) kinda looks like a fish: lips are a little thick and eyes are a little big. However, I love the costume and the lighting. Really dedicated to the real thing.
Yeahs0 -
03/20/2016 12:07 PM ·Spoilers
I'm not fighting, I'm just speaking my mind about critique posts and their flaws. Users are asked to come along and be honest, but even when one has the best intentions, they still end up being called a hater. My post up there wasn't that bad was it? It's really a great drawing, it's the post system I find terribly flawed.
This comment contains spoilers.
Yeahs0 -
03/20/2016 12:12 PM ·Spoilers
Constructive criticism is sharing your opinion on something and providing why in a valid a well-reasoned way, positive and negative. What it is: "I like how you..." "I think this can be improved by..." When an artist is willing to improve and wants criticism, it -should- mean that they acknowledge that there's flaws and want to know what can be improved or what they're already doing right.
Yeahs2 -
03/20/2016 12:13 PM ·Spoilers
Saying something negative doesn't make it rude unless it's put in a rude way. But it may not always be welcome when it's unsolicited, even if you're just trying to help. And some just take it the wrong way. What it's NOT: "I like it." "I hate it." "It's great!" What about it do you like/dislike? Simply praising isn't very helpful if someone wants to improve, as encouraging as it may be.
Yeahs2 -
03/20/2016 12:23 PM ·Spoilers
Constructive criticism doesn't need to include both positive and negative points, but by stating the positives you show that you're on their side and want to support what they're doing, and can make it easier to digest the negative points. Put simply, it's giving feedback without being a jerk and by being specific as you can. Suggesting ways to improve is also a big plus if you're knowledgeable.
Yeahs2 -
03/20/2016 12:32 PM ·Spoilers
I appreciate the explanation, @Krauss. Seriously, this insight is why I follow ya. Although I don't consider myself to be a jerk, and I try real hard to follow similar rules, it's getting harder to speak freely without being called things. This situation turned out great. I can count the many ways it could've gone wrong but didn't, and I thank everyone for being so cool about this.
Yeahs0 -
03/20/2016 12:57 PM ·Spoilers
Thank you for your opinion V, and not rude or anything. Always feel free to speak your mind and stuff. And thank you for the explanation panda krauss
Yeahs1Played
Add a Comment
You must sign in to post a comment.
Sign in using a Nintendo Network ID to connect to users around the world by writing posts and comments and by giving Yeahs to other people's posts. You can create a Nintendo Network ID using your Wii U console or your system in the Nintendo 3DS family.
Report Violation to Miiverse Administrators
You are about to report a post with content which violates the Miiverse Code of Conduct. This report will be sent to Nintendo's Miiverse administrators and not to the creator of the post.
Report Violation to Miiverse Administrators
You cannot report posts made automatically by a software title.














